Sometimes the biggest changes are actually tiny. In a year-long clinical trial, researchers found that changing the angle of a person’s foot while walking cut knee osteoarthritis pain by an amount comparable to some medications, while also slowing deterioration in a marker of cartilage health.
The study, published in The Lancet Rheumatology, tested personalised gait retraining in 68 people with mild to moderate osteoarthritis affecting the inner part of the knee. Researchers from the University of Utah, New York University and Stanford University randomly assigned 34 people to receive personalised walking instructions and 34 to a sham treatment.
“We’ve known that for people with osteoarthritis, higher loads in their knee accelerate progression, and that changing the foot angle can reduce knee load,” said Scott Uhlrich, an assistant professor of mechanical engineering at the University of Utah. “So the idea of a biomechanical intervention is not new, but there have not been randomized, placebo-controlled studies to show that they’re effective.”
Participants first had MRI scans and walked on a sensor-equipped treadmill while motion capture cameras recorded how changes in foot position affected pressure on the knee. They tested turning their toes inward or outward by 5 degrees or 10 degrees, and researchers selected the adjustment that best reduced loading on the affected knee for each person.
“Previous trials prescribed the same intervention to all individuals, resulting in some individuals not reducing, or even increasing, their joint loading,” Uhlrich said. “We used a personalized approach to selecting each individual’s new walking pattern, which improved how much individuals could offload their knee and likely contributed to the positive effect on pain and cartilage that we saw.”
Some prospective participants were excluded because none of the tested adjustments reduced their knee loading.
Both groups then completed six weekly training sessions. Participants walked on a treadmill wearing a device on their shin that gave gentle vibrations when their foot moved outside the prescribed angle. After six weeks, they were told to practise the technique for at least 20 minutes a day.
After one year, the intervention group reported an average pain improvement of 2.5 points on a zero-to-10 scale, compared with 1.3 points in the sham group. In an exploratory analysis, about 91 percent of participants in the personalised retraining group had a clinically meaningful reduction in pain, compared with 66 percent in the comparison group.
Researchers also found the intervention reduced a mechanical measure linked to pressure on the inner knee. MRI scans showed slower degradation in one marker of cartilage health, known as T1rho, in the intervention group. A second MRI measure did not show a significant difference between the groups.
“The reported decrease in pain over the placebo group was somewhere between what you’d expect from an over-the-counter medication, like ibuprofen, and a narcotic, like OxyContin,” Uhlrich said. “With the MRIs, we also saw slower degradation of a marker of cartilage health in the intervention group, which was quite exciting.”
No severe adverse events were reported. Two participants in the intervention group and one in the sham group withdrew because of increased knee pain.
The researchers said the treatment is not ready for widespread clinical use. The trial included only 68 participants, all with mild to moderate osteoarthritis in the inner knee, and only those whose joint loading improved with at least one tested walking adjustment.
“Especially for people in their 30s, 40s, or 50s, osteoarthritis could mean decades of pain management before they’re recommended for a joint replacement,” Uhlrich said. “This intervention could help fill that large treatment gap.”
Uhlrich said researchers are working on ways to deliver the approach outside specialised labs.
“We and others have developed technology that could be used to both personalize and deliver this intervention in a clinical setting using mobile sensors, like smartphone video and a ‘smart shoe’,” Uhlrich said.
Read more from Science Daily.




